I just started getting into Mutations, a book that I bought a few weeks ago when I was in Chicago. Javier f
irst found it in the library of the Architectural School at IIT and it was so fascinating that we ended up buying it elsewhere. It has various contributors, including modern architect Rem Koolhaas with the Harvard Project on the City, Stanford Kwitter and Saskia Sassen.
I browsed through this book for hours at first, looking at the photos and statistics and thinking about how everything in this book relates to everything I learned as an undergraduate student of Anthropology some years back.
And it got me to thinking of some of the large cities that I’ve visited over the years - Hamburg, Paris, Prague, London, New York, San Francisco, Tokyo and Buenos Aires to name a few. I suppose too, that it’s part of my analytical nature to begin to categorize my thoughts on each place I visited and really begin to form an
opinion about some of these great cities. One conclusion that I am beginning to understand is that Tokyo, although a very important, immense and globalized city, is not a very cosmopolitan city at all.
For example, even though the city of Tokyo is the site of many companies who have dispersed their economic activities throughout the world (i.e.: globalized businesses) and imported some non-Japanese people to work in these companies, the population and identity of Japan and particularly Tokyo remains strongly Japanese. Of course, there are products of tourism. There are a lot of signs in romanji (Japanese using English letters); there are imported goods in the grocery stores; there are a handful of foreign restaurants. The cultural diversity of the city is due mostly to tourism however, as foreigners only make up less than 2% of the population. Equally, maintaining that strong national identity is probably of great help to tourism and their economy.
If all of a sudden, Japan became known as almost American in its ways, my perceived value of a “trip to Japan” would be lowered. Equally, if they didn’t maintain the global perception that the Japanese themselves are innovators of technology and leaders in this market, there would be a possibility of decreased value of their products. Yeah, I’m talking possibilities… Tokyo is really global, not in a cosmopolitan sense but in a sense that it’s an important, immense urban city whose economy and innovation has worldwide relevance.
So, if you leave Tokyo and go to the rest of Japan, what do you see? There’s a Japanese culture that exists outside of Tokyo. It’s a culture influenced with an extraordinarily long history, ancient religions, a government that partially mandates the national identity, multiple environmental issues (including overpopulation and natural disasters such as earthquakes) and the idea of community as a more or less “family”.
In Kyoto which was the capital for several hundred years before Tokyo, we would be stopped at a bus stop or riding along in a bus and someone (usually an older gentleman) would strike up a conversation with us (in English!) asking us where we are from, what we like to do, how is our country, etc. In Osaka, a much larger city, we found the city center itself immense - and although fewer people spoke English there, (aside from
this awesome guy named Bucky that we met in the street asking for directions and he ended up walking with us for several blocks and telling us about Osaka). We ended eating some fried octopus at one of the best known places for this food in the city. (Thanks Bucky!) And then we met up with my friend Yoshi (we knew each other from way back in the day in Chicago) and went out to see great architecture and eat raw chicken (oh yeah, good stuff)! But in the streets, the (almost Latino) people drive fast and beep their horns and in general, just seemed more relaxed than in Tokyo. They were easier to connect to - they were more open. But in Osaka, we noted that gringo tourism wasn’t as prevalent as Tokyo, Kyoto, Himeji or Hiroshima. It’s kind of the forgotten city - and certainly my favorite of all in Japan.
Ok - that’s it on Japan. Back to Buenos Aires.



sometimes really amazing “traveling galleries” passing in front of you while you sat on your bike or in your car. Even walking down the streets, there would be wonderful murals on the walls - paintings of influential individuals or whatever expression that the artist felt was important to share with the world at the time. And the artist does put the time and effort into the work, knowing full well that it lasts only for a limited amount of time.
truck out to blast it with a powerful water based cleanser - leaving the ghost of the fading art behind. And to be honest with you - that really saddens me.
